San Mateo can enhance its housing solutions by adopting streamlined ADU permitting processes and encouraging legal constructions, as demonstrated by Los Angeles. Focusing on rapid strategies and community engagement will mitigate challenges and maximize the benefits of ADU developments.
Introduction to ADU Zoning in Los Angeles
Los Angeles has focused significantly on Accessory Dwelling Units (ADUs) as part of its zoning policies. ADUs, or secondary housing units, have become essential to address the city's housing crisis. Key policies and regulations have been implemented to streamline ADU approvals and construction.
One major policy is Executive Directive 1 (ED 1), aimed at accelerating the construction of 100% affordable housing. Signed by Mayor Karen Bass in 2022, ED 1 fast-tracks the bureaucratic review process for housing construction applications. However, this directive has seen controversy due to its perceived loopholes, which some fear could lead to large developments overshadowing smaller historic homes.
Key points about ADU zoning in Los Angeles include:
Executive Directive 1 (ED 1): Encourages affordable housing but has been criticized for loopholes that may benefit developers.
Citywide Housing Incentive Program (CHIP): Offers incentives like increased density and height allowances in exchange for on-site affordable housing units.
Community Involvement: Neighborhood associations, under United Neighbors (UN), have worked to influence rezoning maps to protect single-family and sensitive multi-family zones.
These policies aim to balance the demand for higher housing density with community preservation. The discussions and changes in zoning policies highlight how cities like Los Angeles are dealing with complex housing issues, providing valuable lessons for other cities like San Mateo.
Success Stories from LA: Increased Housing and Affordability
San Mateo's integration of Accessory Dwelling Units (ADUs) can greatly benefit from observing successful implementations in Los Angeles (LA). In LA, ADUs have helped increase the housing supply and improve affordability.
Key Insights from LA’s Success with ADUs:
Diverse Developments:
Converted garages
Infill lot constructions
Custom prefab builds
Advantages of ADUs in LA:
Extra income for homeowners
Housing solutions for families and communities
Maintained community aesthetics
Important Steps:
Define the goal of the ADU project
Explore financing options
Plan thoroughly with professionals (architects and contractors)
Case Study: Jefferson Schierbeek and Su Addison
Los Angeles architects Jefferson Schierbeek and Su Addison built a 300-square-foot ADU above their garage. This unit, now rented for $1,750 per month, showcases successful ADU implementation. Their focus was on:
Functionality and privacy
Inventive storage solutions
Strategic window placements
Eco-friendly designs
By incorporating innovative elements like sharing communal spaces, they fostered community bonds. Their experience underscores the potential financial and community benefits of ADUs.
Legislative Support
California offers financial assistance and permits homeowners to sell ADUs like condominiums. This legal support is crucial for boosting homeownership and making ADU projects viable. San Mateo should consider similar policies.
Lessons for San Mateo
Focus on Rapid and Adaptive Strategies:
Plan according to changing regulations
Prioritize timely construction to avoid delays and budget overruns
San Mateo can leverage these insights to develop effective ADU strategies, addressing housing demands and fostering sustainable community development.
Challenges Faced in Los Angeles' ADU Implementation
Los Angeles encountered several challenges in implementing ADU policies. High construction costs are a significant barrier, with prices starting at $150,000 for simple projects like garage conversions and increasing with additional site or utility complications. While financial programs like the California Housing Finance Agency's ADU Grant Program can relieve some financial burdens, costs remain a primary concern for many homeowners.
Neighborhood opposition is another major challenge. Even when neighbors can't legally stop ADU construction, their resistance can create conflict and delays. Effective communication with the community and adherence to local regulations can help mitigate these issues.
Navigating design and building codes adds another layer of complexity. Los Angeles offers preapproved designs, which can streamline the process, but many homeowners opt for custom designs that better meet their needs, driving up costs and potentially causing further delays. Prefabricated units are an alternative, being quicker and sometimes more cost-effective.
These challenges illustrate the importance of thorough preparation, community engagement, and leveraging available resources. As San Mateo aims to increase ADU adoption, closely examining Los Angeles’ experience will be key to addressing similar setbacks and ensuring successful implementation.
What San Mateo Can Learn: Opportunities and Cautions
San Mateo can glean valuable lessons from Los Angeles' experience with Accessory Dwelling Units (ADUs). ADUs have demonstrated numerous benefits, both economic and social, as well as challenges that need addressing.
However, challenges accompany these benefits:
Unpermitted ADUs: In the Bay Area, a study by Stanford found that many ADUs are built without permits. In San Jose, about 1,000 of the 1,300 ADUs constructed between 2016 and 2020 lacked proper permits.
Lengthy Permitting Processes: Contractors face hurdles such as extended permitting times, which discourage legal ADU construction.
Economic and Equity Issues: Unpermitted ADUs often arise in lower-income and dense communities, exacerbating housing inequities. Policymakers must consider legalization and amnesty programs to support affordable housing development.
Insights from Los Angeles indicate a need for streamlined permitting processes in San Mateo. Simplifying the steps to get plans approved and reducing associated fees could promote legal ADU construction, benefiting homeowners and families. With proper planning and regulatory support, San Mateo can harness the economic and social advantages of ADUs while mitigating associated challenges.
FAQ
What are Accessory Dwelling Units (ADUs)?
Accessory Dwelling Units (ADUs) are secondary housing units built on the same property as a primary residence. They are used to add extra living space and address housing shortages.
What is Executive Directive 1 (ED 1) in Los Angeles?
Executive Directive 1 (ED 1) is a policy aimed at accelerating the construction of affordable housing in Los Angeles by fast-tracking the bureaucratic review process for housing construction applications.
What incentives does Los Angeles offer for ADU construction?
Los Angeles offers incentives such as the Citywide Housing Incentive Program (CHIP), which includes increased density and height allowances in exchange for on-site affordable housing units.
How have ADUs benefited homeowners in Los Angeles?
ADUs have provided homeowners in Los Angeles with extra income, additional housing solutions for families and communities, and have helped maintain community aesthetics.
What are some common types of ADU developments in Los Angeles?
In Los Angeles, ADUs commonly include converted garages, infill lot constructions, and custom prefab builds.
Can you provide a success story of ADU implementation in Los Angeles?
Yes, architects Jefferson Schierbeek and Su Addison built a 300-square-foot ADU above their garage in Los Angeles. They rented it out for $1,750 a month, showcasing how ADUs can be functional, private, and eco-friendly while offering financial returns.
What support does California provide for ADU projects?
California offers financial assistance and permits homeowners to sell ADUs like condominiums, boosting homeownership and making ADU projects more viable.
What challenges has Los Angeles faced in implementing ADU policies?
Los Angeles has faced several challenges including high construction costs, neighborhood opposition, and navigating complex design and building codes.
How can San Mateo benefit from Los Angeles' experience with ADUs?
San Mateo can benefit by observing successful ADU implementations in Los Angeles, leveraging state legislative support, and adopting streamlined permitting processes to encourage legal ADU construction.
What are some issues with unpermitted ADUs?
Unpermitted ADUs often arise in lower-income and dense communities and can exacerbate housing inequities. Lengthy permitting processes also discourage legal construction, emphasizing the need for streamlining and support programs.
Sources Used in the Article
The article references several sources including an analysis on changing zoning rules for housing by OPB, an overview by Larchmont Chronicle on urban design efforts, insights from the Los Angeles Times on obstacles to ADU construction, and research by CBS News on the issue of unpermitted ADUs. These sources provided valuable context and data.
Comentarios